Deena Metzger
In order to learn how to write, Deena walked alone along the bay and beaches of Sea Gate, bordered by Coney Island and the Atlantic Ocean. As a child, she walked during the days or early evenings because she knew a writer needed to see and then later and later at night, each night, in order to see within. Watching her father’s devotion to writing, to other writers, to the Jewish community, she also learned early on that writing is a sacred activity on behalf of a future. Her father didn’t know if his people or his language, Yiddish, would survive the century and Deena understood quite quickly that all the lives on Earth, those of the natural world and also the human lives, were imperiled by extinction and that the same minds that have threatened genocide are also threatening ecocide. Accordingly, she committed herself to bearing witness, teaching, offering healing, gathering community – it doesn’t matter which – and she is always seeking to align the word, the insight, the need, the Story for the sake of Earth’s survival. She is a novelist, non-fiction writer, poet, playwright, essayist, storyteller, medicine woman and healer, considered by many a visionary, feminist and ecological thinker, and an explorer of imaginal realms. Early in her writing life, she began to imagine a Literature of Restoration to meet these broken times. And oh yes, she regularly meets with Elephants in the wild, particularly the one who has come to be called The Ambassador.
ABOUT
Deena Metzger
A poet, novelist, essayist, storyteller, teacher, healer and medicine woman who has been thinking about LoR for 20 years.
” Deena gives us the prescription for healing our personal and collective split through becoming conscious of these forces and their interplay in the human ceremony called relationship.”
– Eduardo Duran
La Vieja, Chapter 7
BY DEENA METZGER
It is believed that animal nature helped to create humans and that animals have always served as humanity's mentors in coming to know the nature of the world.
Gregory Cajete, Native Science: Natural Laws of Interdependence
I had wanted to meet Lawrence Anthony when I learned of him and the wild animal preserve he had founded at Thula Thula in South Africa. Later, he had gotten the understanding or the message, the gut knowing, the insight, the urge, the great idea, the light bulb going off, that as the Americans were invading Iraq, the animals in Saddam Hussein’s zoo needed care or they would die terrible deaths, the best of which would be being eaten. Immediately, he boarded an airplane and made his way to Babylon, that is Baghdad, shrewdly engaged American military support, protection, trucks and food that allowed him to save many of the animals that Hussein had collected in the Baghdad zoo. I wanted to talk with him when I read in his book, The Last Rhinos: My Battle to Save One of the World’s Greatest Creatures of his being “drafted” by Joseph Kony of the Lord’s Resistance Army who controlled a preserve which had just become a war zone. Kony invited him—if a demand from a warlord made directly by one of his associates can be considered an invitation—to broker peace under UN auspices between Kony’s forces and the Ugandan government in return for Kony protecting the last Rhinos who resided there, already critically endangered by poachers. Anthony traveled, as required, unaccompanied and unarmed to Kony’s secret camp and forthwith did broker the deal which, however, did not last long because the Ugandan government would not be receiving funds from the US unless it was at war. And it needed the money.
But what had truly drawn me to Anthony was that he had spent all night, each night, for several months directly outside the boma enclosing the Elephants he had rescued so that they would begin to trust him, would perceive with their extreme sensitivity who he was, and over time accept that he had brought them to his land in order to save their lives. He under- stood when they first broke out of the makeshift enclosure he had erected, they were suffering the trauma of being removed from their own sacred land after a rancher threatened to shoot them because they were, in the local farmers’ words, vandalizing their crops, notwithstanding that they were just seeking food for themselves and their little ones where they had foraged for hundreds of years. And so they were transferred by truck to a strange place and confined until they accommodated, (capitulated), and until a large enough enclosure was secured. Anthony and the Elephants bonded finally and found true ways to communicate across the species barrier, Lawrence Anthony and his ranger reaching out, hour after hour, to Nana, the Elephant Matriarch, and later to Frankie who, when the two small herds merged, became Nana’s lineage holder, dharma heir.
When he died very suddenly, in Johannesburg, hours before he received a major award, the Elephants came to his house to acknowledge that they knew and to mourn him in their ceremonial way, an act they also understood would reveal their true nature to the world through him. And so, even though he died before I could meet him, I had to go and be on his land and in his presence and with the Elephants whom he had befriended. But I would not have gone without an invitation—I would not. And it was not, as you must understand, an invitation from Anthony or his people.
I asked the ranger at Thula Thula if he could take me to a place where it was likely that I would meet the Matriarch as she made her daily rounds. He hesitated, wary of imposing upon her in any way. “We will go where we go,” he said, “and she will be there or not.” We began to argue, although I was impressed by his adamant concern for the Elephants above the desires of a visitor.
Still, I said, “But you don’t understand. I’m only here in answer to her invitation.” He was very dubious though trying to disguise the level of in- credulity he felt, and, naturally, I didn’t have a letter or any proof. She had written on the wind or drummed their invitation on the earth in the ways her people are able to sound the alarm when culls occur and are perceived and understood precisely, even 100 miles distant. Even farther. Elephants’ ability to communicate is not limited by science’s ability to trace and verify the message.
“Why did she invite you?” the ranger asked as if sincerely entering the conversation.
“I believe a distant relative of hers suggested it. We’ve been meeting regularly in his territory over almost twenty years. He was the one who called me first and I came. Well, I am not sure he called me. It is equally possible, that he and his people, put out a universal call, and I am one of those who responded. Who knows who else received and who answered which call from which Elephants and where they met, if they did, and how? But I am the one who has lived this particular story for twenty years.
“I had been traveling with a group of people and we ended up at a certain tree at the side of the road across from a shallow pond pooling out from the river, and this became our ongoing meeting place every time we returned. A bird had landed on the tree while we were looking to meet whomever would appear. As it happened, the bird, a Fisher Eagle, Chapungu, was sacred to my friend who was driving and he refused to leave as long as the bird was there. Ultimately, the Elephant we now call the Ambassador, showed up. We had exchanges. I had brought my people and he had brought his.”
“How did you know it was him?”
“You couldn’t mistake the circumstances then, nor since, even though they vary from year to year. The fact of the meetings is incontrovertible; they play out like improvisational theater pieces that progress to tell a story from each of our interactions and we are all parties to it. I wasn’t alone as an observer or participant. There were witnesses. Professional, unbiased and skeptical. They each played a role.”
“And so he told you where to go next?” The Ranger was testy.
“Oh no. Eighteen years later, she sent us the call. Of this I am also almost certain, because this time, I received very particular instructions regarding etiquette, which I had never received before. Nor could I have as I didn’t know the first time whom I was going to meet, only that an over- whelming longing for such a meeting was instilled in me which I could not resist no matter the effort and cost. I had told my traveling companions, ‘I want to sit in council with the Elephant people.’ And so we went where we might meet them and then he came.”
“Is that why you went originally?” The Ranger was going over the territory again as if I hadn’t spoken of this, trying to find the loopholes, the fantasy that he could then dismiss. Patience was required to navigate this exchange.
“Yes.”
“And he was waiting there?”
“No, he wasn’t waiting. We waited for him. You see, given the way we humans are behaving in relation to animals and the Earth, we had to make significant gestures to show we were trustworthy. It wasn’t enough to come from the West Coast of the US, we had to be willing to wait. And so we did. We came looking for the opportunity to have an exchange. He came at almost the last hour of the last day. He was testing us. Of course, he was.”
The Ranger’s discomfort was increasing; the story is so unlikely. He must have been thinking, this woman is mad. But if it were a true story, he was obligated to bring us to her, and also if he brought us, the gesture implied his endorsement. Despite his overwhelming skepticism, he would have to accept the consequences. To do so, he had to be willing to trust us, or at least give us the benefit of the doubt and also to admit and follow his great hope that what I was relating was possible. If real, this situation had incredible implications for inter-species communication particularly because it was occurring at Thula Thula where Anthony had pioneered such a connection.
Assessing a situation, deciding whether to trust someone or not, predicting behavior, negotiating tense circumstances were skills the Ranger honed because he guided people in the wild, but he usually didn’t have to apply them to what his passengers in his vehicle said about Elephants they didn’t know; constraining their behavior was task enough.
I continued telling the story in as casual and sober way I could.
“Oh no, he certainly wasn’t waiting for us.” I laughed, accepting being cross-examined. “We had to go out each day for several days and look for him. We had to find the place where he might be.”
“It could have been anywhere?”
“Yes.”
“And you didn’t have any way to recognize him, so he could have been anyone?”
“Yes.”
“But it sounds like you met him. Did he just turn up?”
“We were running out of time. It was the last day and almost the last hour we could be in his area. We were leaving the next day. And we still didn’t know where to go. Our hunt felt increasingly futile, and even foolish. We had come such a long distance.
“Then, as I told you, my colleague, who was driving, saw something, saw the bird, the Fisher Eagle, his totem which indicated that we must stop where we were. Whether or not it was the place, he wouldn’t go on. He turned off the engine. In his mind, we had been brought to this place for reasons we couldn’t anticipate. We had to wait and be open to whatever came to us. He was no longer looking for Elephants. He was in the sacred place of the Chapungu bird and he was exulting in its presence.
“Sometime after we had parked under the tree, I saw an Elephant far down the road along the river and prayed it was him. In my innocence, I prayed that I could call him to us telepathically, without recognizing that it was he who had called us a far greater distance from the US to Africa.
“He walked so slowly to us; it must have taken a thousand days. This was one of my first experiences that time does not exist in the way we presume it does. It took so long a time because we were being prepared to see who was before us. And then a similarly infinite time passed while he allowed me to gaze into his eyes and penetrated mine so that we could step over the line, which has separated us for thousands of years. We entered into a profound and inexplicable silent exchange.”
“What did he say?”
“To translate into English would diminish what occurred between us. We speak entirely different languages, each arising from different histories, world views, circumstances and experiences. His lineage, ancient compared to ours, was developed painstakingly over millions of years. Accordingly, his communications would be far more difficult for us to comprehend. In his presence, I quickly knew that he did not need language in order to communicate and that my words, being limited by my culture, would diminish our connection.”
“He wasn’t limited?”
“Not by his languages. He didn’t use language.”
“He came very, very close to me. I felt no harm would come. History was written on his face, the distances he had traveled, the dangers and their tentative resolutions. He let me see this and was cognizant of what I was able to perceive. We looked into each other’s eyes, each of us entirely open to the other. Clearly, he was leading; I was trying to follow. Time stopped and passed simultaneously. Left to time as I know it, what would have literally taken eons occurred within our comparatively few minutes together. Our half an hour equaled infinity. I was grateful that in such a short period of time, we were able to grasp that he is a peer. More than a peer. I felt the enormity of his presence, intellect and agency. He was orchestrating our meeting. I was grateful that I could respond. I believe the purpose was for me as a two-legged to fully understand and accept our common denominator as distinct and equal beings. I fully accepted, though he would not insist upon it—he is too great a being to do so—that he had rank and I did not in this interaction. Perhaps we are not peers. More likely, we are, as the Kogi say, merely the young ones and he and his people are the Elders, the Elder Brothers.
“I don’t know how to convey what happens within one when we are open to a great Presence. It was Epiphany, January 6, 1999. Later, remembering this brought awe, disbelief and then a little humor to relieve us of the enormity of the event. But before that, when I was beginning to glimpse what was occurring, I did speak to him in my mind believing he would understand my language, that he had that capacity.
“I said, ‘We both come from a Holocausted people and so, I promise you, your people are my people.’”
“So do you think he understood?” the Ranger asked.
“Well, over the years, he came again and again and again. He came every time we returned to that place. He understands more than I understand. I only know he called us. What sphere of intelligence does this reveal? I can’t assess it. I don’t understand it.
“After about a half hour, I glanced as my watch. It was exactly time to leave the park before it closed. He must have known this as he leaped up in the same moment, spun around and disappeared into the bush. Although forbidden to be outside a vehicle, we all jumped out of the pickup and col- lapsed on the ground. Several of us were weeping. But we were late and we had to recover quickly, mount up. We set out regretfully and slowly.
“And then … and then … and then … his people started coming down from above the hill and from among the trees behind us, little ones and matriarchs, great bulls, small groups, a small migration. They arranged themselves quietly and with great dignity facing us alongside a mile of the river road. Not one of us had ever seen such a lineup before or since, nor any photos of such. We did not know if the flood of animals had finished but we knew that one must never come between a female and her young, and yet we could not find another way to go except along the river way they were occupying. And so we set out trusting that our perception was correct: they were waiting for us now. As we proceeded, there was no danger although there could have been. There was only our slow and careful procession and their subtle but undeniable acknowledgement that we had come a great distance and, perhaps, most importantly, that we had heard and felt the call—the longing they had instilled in us. That we saw who they are. That some humans have the capacity to recognize the presence of the gods when they appear. Our understanding of the nature of the world was shattered by this beauty and now we live in Mystery and awe. Whatever occurred it came from beyond and was beyond us and remains so.”
The Ranger fiddled with his intercom as I probed the brush with my camera. He needed time. Then I began speaking again.
“That first meeting was almost twenty years ago. We have met since. And now we are here. We heard a call again. This time we could discern who sent it. It brought us here. As we were preparing to come, we learned there is a protocol to be followed. We hadn’t known this but could have anticipated it if we were wiser. We received instructions, and this is what I am trying to explain.
“We have been instructed upon arrival to go with you to a neutral place that you know and wait for the Matriarch to appear. When she does, I am to introduce myself and my people, briefly describing our history and intent. You know how this is done with a minimum of words, if any. We will open ourselves fully and she will read who we are. Then, I am to ask permission to be here and to be among them. We, my people, Cynthia Travis and I, are to pledge our willingness and commitment to honor her and her people’s sovereignty, to take nothing from her or her people and to commit to protect them—from such as we are—as best we can. Nothing less will gain us entrance to their domain.
“I understand,” I continued to the Ranger, “from your hesitancy and caution, that you are trustworthy in relationship to her which is what matters most. She knows that you will be the one to bring us and has probably arranged it. Still, it is up to you, though she will as we travel find us on her own if that is her intention. Each one of us has to meet issues of trust. These are such times.” He turned away from us and looked out at the road. We sat still, waiting. Then he started the truck again and we continued touring the area without any signs of Elephants that day.
We went out early the next morning and the Ranger parked in a field that they often traverse in such a way that we would not be blocking their familiar path. They could, if they came by, greet us or not as they wished. Drought was taking its toll and they might go anywhere to search for water. This spot was on a little plain above the valley even though they were more likely to find hidden springs with remains of mud, if not running water, below. The sun rose high and it was very hot. We had to wait a long time, and we expected as much. Then they came slowly through the bush.
Nana walked regally as she does, and we were aware that she saw us and was taking our measure. She did not stop but walked around the Rover so that she could examine us from every angle. It had a canvas roof, but no windows and we were completely exposed. Her people were following her. She may be slightly apart, but she is never away from them. And then, equally slowly, we saw her deputy, Frankie, the Matriarch-in-training, approaching. Frankie stopped and waited searchingly. Nana was behind me and as this was her choice, I did not turn around, but proceeded as I had been instructed to introduce myself and the others. I told her that we had received their call and were honoring it. If she and her people were willing, we would like to be among them for several days so that we could learn whatever it is they wish us to know, that we would honor the transmissions received and consider deeply what we were called to do. I told her we were not anthropologists or the equivalent for the animal world.
Frankie nodded in her way and encircled us as Nana had done, clearly giving the little ones permission to explore us with their trunks, and then they left. Over the next days we met again and again. As has been the case each time, there is no way we could predict or anticipate what might occur, the way daily events ultimately conjoined to translate into direct communications.
One day, Frankie and her extended family surrounded us as they had the first time. We had our eyes locked on each other. There was tension in the air and I could feel that the Ranger was wary though he didn’t say any- thing to us. He hesitated before he turned off the engine, kept his hand near the key and did not lean back in his seat as he had in the past. I was not afraid but concerned that I, we, might miss something in our ignorance of their ways. Then Frankie seemed to twitch with impatience and left my side to go to the other side of the vehicle where she caught my eye again as I turned to her. I knew this was a critical moment but not how to meet it. Then she spoke directly into my heart. There was no pretending her words weren’t clear.
“Do you know,” she asked, her eyes piercing, “how hard it is to be the matriarch for my people when I can’t find water for them to drink and I am unable to leave this preserve to search for it? If, it exists anywhere at all. If your people haven’t consumed it all.”
There was a complex back story behind her inquiry. She acknowledged that she and her people had been given sanctuary on this land and otherwise they would have been shot where they had been living because farms had been established where they had foraged and they tried to eat what they could, what was there, what belonged to them, but now they were facing the consequences of their imprisonment. She was not able to exercise her major responsibility to lead them to food and water wherever it might be.
On our arrival, a group of guests had been greatly delayed for dinner. When they arrived, they said they had stopped to free a baby Nyala from a mud hole. But in only a few days, the mud had become dry and cracked. It had not rained for a long time. Our water was being trucked in from Richard’s Bay and the Native people on the hills surrounding the valley of Thula Thula were demonstrating, burning tires, blocking the roads because the water infrastructure promised them by the candidates in the last election had never materialized.
“She sometimes gets testy,” our guide said, “it’s probably time for us to go.”
“No,” I said, “she spoke to me,” hoping he would understand that I couldn’t leave until she did. When she, herself turned and led the younger Elephants to a grove of ripe fig trees, we stayed some distance watching them in happy camaraderie with each other, and left as well. When we were almost down the hill toward our encampment we saw that Frankie and Nana were leading the herd down the hill, but rather than keeping to the road as is their habit, they were walking parallel to us, slightly behind, with slow deliberation.
“Do they ever come to the camp?” I asked. Our guide seemed distressed. “They are enacting their water witching skills,” he said, concerned. “They are walking along the buried water pipeline and in some hundred feet they will come to the only place the pipes go above ground to bring water to the lodge for the guests. Once, at a similar time of drought, they broke the pipes to get the water.”
That afternoon, the Native villagers had commandeered the water truck headed for the Reserve. Frankly, we all cheered them as the action forced the government to deliver the water that was rightfully theirs. Now the Elephants stood very still facing the employees’ and the guests’ tents. Their behavior was not threatening, but it was exquisitely articulate.
Frankie stood closest to my tent. It looked like a casual choice. No one else noticed how precisely she had positioned herself. She stayed there a long time and seemed to be pointing at the pipes with her trunk and then she slid her foot back and forth until she had shaped a foot width trench very close to the pipe. I was sitting on the porch looking at her, imagining her sliding her tusk under the pipe and raising it up, then raising her trunk higher until the water pipe broke and the water ran into the furrow which quickly became a stream. Had she planted the image in my mind? I wouldn’t have conceived it myself. Francoise Anthony, Lawrence’s widow, joined us for drinks that night. She drank a dry sherry and I had an Irish whiskey, neat. The contrast be- tween our indulgence, the Elephant’s anguish, and the Native people’s desperation was obvious. But the Elephants had invited us, had directed us to stay here, and were revealing their unhappy situation to us. Francoise’s deft avoidance of the subject of rain and water was, in itself, eloquent. But somehow, it had also been decided that Thula Thula would fill a few water holes for the Elephants. (And the Native people had won assurances that municipal water, enough for their needs would be delivered to them as needed.) Once this was guaranteed, we watched the Elephants leave in a slow and ponderous way, each step, usually so silent, a statement which we learned by the time dessert was served included advising us that they did not want to drink from metal tanks. That was made clear from the way they had stood by the water holes even as the tanks were being filled. Standing without moving was the language they seemed to have developed so there would be no confusion about their intent. They had been confined in a boma, they had yielded to human will, they had made peace with Lawrence Anthony. But he was in the clouds now and still there was no rain. They were wild, but they were not aggressive animals unless they had witnessed a cull, unless the young ones had seen the matriarchs slaughtered by AK47s fired from helicopters, unless the young bulls had no elders to guide them, unless they were fenced in, unless they were confined in a zoo or made to perform in a circus, unless they were tortured with bull hooks and electric prods. The combined two herds living at Thula Thula were pacific in nature, but, they wanted us to know, from the tension that characterized their stillness, that they could, if they remained without water, take us down. As we were finishing dinner, a guest who had retired early to take a shower came screaming into the dining area, in her robe with a towel wrapped around her red hair. When they could make out what she was saying, two guards ran off to her tent and ultimately we learned that when she turned away in her outdoor shower from the wall to the trees, she saw a Cobra with its head raised staring at her. She leaped toward the doorway and ran to us. Even a Koperkapel gets thirsty, the guards informed us when they returned from banishing it to an abandoned termite mound they thought it would like. Calmer and assured the Snake would not return, she described the water pouring down on the stone footing, the relief from the heat and dryness of the safari ride, and the terror she felt when she turned to see the cobra with its flared head looking at her or at the water, she couldn’t tell. She hadn’t turned the water off—the cobra must have drunk its fill. Fortunately the precious water hadn’t run too long or perhaps other animals had taken it in as had, most surely, the roots of the trees. Each night afterwards, we nodded to each other as we separated to sleep, indicating that we would pray for rain, not only for the people, who were suffering among other afflictions, our privilege, but, particularly for the Elephants and the animals. Whatever I knew about calling rain, I kept to myself. On the very last day, we set out to say goodbye to the Elephants on the way to the airport. The weather was awful. No, the weather was magnificent in that everyone’s prayers for rain had been answered in an ongoing downpour the day before The ponds, the pools, the mudflats, the streams, the roads were all flooding. The Ranger reluctantly agreed to try a precarious road but he would only go so far because we had gotten stuck in the mud the night before after the rain and we couldn’t risk it. On the other hand, these were our last hours and so he had to try though he doubted that we would find them. We and he had become comrades and were clear about the need to enact reciprocity with each other and all the beings we encountered. He accepted now that we had consistently been greeted by the Ambassador or other Elephants in other areas on the last hour of the last day. The road was muddy and almost impassable, filled with debris. We went slowly, the ranger always wanting to turn back and equally determined to have a final exchange. He was following an intuition, was taking this high and narrow road because now, he was compelled. When we had only minutes to stay until we had to set out for the airport, when we could go no further and reluctantly came to a stop, yielding to fate, we heard faint hums and rumbles, unmistakably the sounds of their communication with each other. Through the silvery mist beginning to shine with intermittent points of light, we saw their great gray shapes silhouetted against the mountain and were filled with gratitude as they turned toward us in acknowledgement. Yes, it was the last hour of the last day that we would be there, and we realized that their relative in the other country, the Ambassador, had told them that meeting, in whatever way, on the last hour of the last day would confirm the magic and great mystery we had entered together over time and space. They had needed reassurance that we would make the effort to find them, needed to know, as much as we did, that it was possible to dissolve into a field of common consciousness on behalf of a future in which we all coexist and thrive. We had come as far as we could, had hit a dead end of mud and a slight landslide which any being would recognize as impassable. They had seen us come to this point. They turned toward us. We greeted them in our hearts, offered tobacco which by now they knew was our sacrament, turned the Rover toward the highway and our departure to resume a life we could not escape despite the harm to our souls and to their lives.
Even as I write this story, having told it so many times, I am shaken by its reality. It shatters all my, our, assumptions about the world. Yes, this happened. This really happened. I, with others, experienced this connection with the Elephant people several times over twenty years. It stunned us every time. We do not pretend to understand. I am left with questions I ask again and again. What is the true nature of the world in which such things happen? And how, then, shall we live?
Just three weeks after we were in Thula Thula, having just returned to the orphanage connected with Thula Thula, a refuge and rehabilitation center for Rhinos and other baby animals who have lost their families to poaching, had held the staff hostage, ripped out the security cameras and shot two 18-month old white Rhinos, Impy and Gugy. The caregivers were savagely beaten and one woman was raped. Both baby Rhinos had their horns brutally removed. One had died after being shot but the other had been defaced while still alive and had to be euthanized.
The night of the poaching, Frankie came to me. I don’t know if it was a dream or a visitation and can’t distinguish the two. She stood in front of me as she had in Thula Thula, assessing me and challenging me to meet her. I was ready to enter the pain she was carrying, put up no barriers against her ongoing awareness of the possibility of annihilation even there in Thula Thula.
I wasn’t back in Africa. Still, she was with me. I was aware of her long tusks resting on the bed the way she had rested them on the hood of the truck. It was for these, I needed to understand, that her people were being slaughtered and brutally so, as it had been for the horns that the little ones had been massacred. The gross absurdity punctured my heart as she could have easily done had she attacked. It was for these, but she wasn’t giving them up. Elephants in Namibia were being born without tusks, not just females, the males as well. But if she were without her tusks she would be severely limited in her ability to perform what was necessary as an Elephant and a Matriarch. It was with these that she accessed groundwater for the herd, warded off attackers, protected or rescued little ones. Her tusks were large and carried a huge price.
Our encounter lasted all night, maybe several nights. Elephants can walk very slowly or run 25 mph even up to 40 mph if required and seem like they are walking. So this proceeding went very slowly. Proceeding? Was this a trial? Oh yes.
She didn’t speak to me but rather it seemed that she opened her mind and drew me in at the speed that I could go so that I was increasingly exposed to her inner cognizance, the world she inhabited and could not escape. Reminding me, she was in prison and disempowered and it had not been her choice to trade her former life for safety, a relative term. It wasn’t that she said this, or that I heard it, but that I had to allow my own mind to disappear and be absorbed into an other’s. Then as the stillness in me deepened and my own thoughts and context dissolved, I was no longer in her mind either but she had passed me on to another and then another Elephant so that the field of their understanding was made plainer to me than I could have imagined. And when the transfer came to a rest, I was in the savannah, which I also knew from many visits over the years. Assessing that I could bear the pain of it, she entered me into the Elephant people’s constant awareness of imminent annihilation by human hands.
Fear, matriarchal fear. I was immersed in it. I was in a lake overgrown with algae. There was not enough oxygen for the beings that live there. Al- most drowning in it, but not. Unable to escape from it. Keeping my trunk above water. A heavy burden. The fear that I might be taken, any time, by a round of bullets from an AK47 delivered from a helicopter, ongoing terror for the species’ extinction. How would they go on without me when I carried the topo map of our two hundred year migration route, the local water map, above and under the surface, survival knowledge developed over millennia (though only rudimentary in defending against the many ways humans attacked) and a deep tactile memory of how it had been once? Once. Before.
There was nothing I could do to safeguard myself and protect myself from my own death though I was considering the danger to the herd if they lost me and what I could do to break out, what I could transmit to them before I died. I felt all of this even as I remembered how I had protected the herd before, what it felt like to be continuously wary, considering what I would do, could do, if danger came. And then it came, and then I plowed forward, my great gray weight plunging, despite how confined I had been, like a tornado bearing down, the others behind me.
I was entirely in Elephant mind and then somehow also in two minds at once as the woman in me queried the Elephant, also in me, “When you carry the gift and curse of such sentience and intelligence and are helpless, do you pray, as humans do, for an unlikely miracle?”
There was no answer but when I was fully restored to myself as human, I prayed for her, and particularly to the Tanzanian Elephant Goddess with the cowry shell skirt, who accompanies the other Elephants on the altar; and so the night or the nights passed.
From this perch, I do wonder if Elephants pray. Prayers imply a division between the penitent and the divine. The Elephants know. Are in the field. Are of it. The Mystery of no distinction simultaneous with individual awareness.
I could feel in the way that specific feeling is a specific intelligence that the Elephants know the ways trees know. The way Earth knows. I could also feel the level of fear that the invading human presence had introduced, unknown until then for fifty million years. They had not had enemies unless weakened, ill or were a baby alone which was unlikely. Each Elephant is considered so precious that when illness or accident takes their lives, profound mourning rituals are enacted. But now death is everywhere and nothing relieves the Matriarch’s newly primal fear of abandoning the herd to slaughter. She didn’t fear her own death. She feared that her death would be accompanied by so many others.
On March 25, 2021, The African Forest Elephant was listed as Critically Endangered and the Savannah Elephant as Endangered. The species is endangered. The Matriarch knows her people may become extinct.
I pray that the savannah Matriarch’s death will be a natural one at the end of a long life, with a Matriarch in training, like Frankie, alongside her preparing a rain of leaves and blossoms and calming the herd that is already walking around her, their orbit winding the old one into the vortex taking her to the other side.
In mid-January 2021, Frankie, the Matriarch, died of liver disease. She had sought out an isolated place to die and was found on January 15. Nana partially resumed the matriarchy, but reluctantly. Frankie’s daughter may assume the role, but it is not certain. There has been no equivalent Matriarch in training.
In Thula Thula, the Elephants have gathered at the foot of the hill where the orphanage is, listening to the howls of mourning, human and non-human alike. They stand still until after the police anti-poaching teams have left. They witnessed the humans putting the little one out of his misery knowing he had witnessed his mother’s similar death and did not leave her body though he was weakened by agonizing pain, lack of food, water and the plenty of grief. That is where he was found when he was taken to the sanctuary.
From their distance, they will wait while a ditch is dug for the two little bodies, while the raped woman is bathed, wrapped in soft hand-woven cloth, tended to carefully by the remaining staff and neighbors; her brothers from one of the surrounding villages standing guard now, enraged. They will discover which of the gang members of Mpumalanga did this deed. In the past, the local judiciary has been very lenient with the Rhino poachers. This time, the brothers say, there will be no mercy. The poachers showed none, they will receive none. Within six months, 365 poachers will be arraigned. While these are the locals who are trying to feed their families since their Indigenous ways of life have been totally destroyed through colonization, the Imperial profiteers are not among those to be fined and sentenced.
The Elephants begin their slow circle of grief below, winding typhoon-like with greater and greater force, gathering all sentient beings into the inescapable center. Without my awareness, they gather me in. Frankie appears where I am sleeping and awakens me in more ways than one.
La Vieja knows this story. And so she stands at her perch searching in all the directions, seeking water as the fires spring up everywhere around her, feeding on the trees.
La Vieja, Chapter 11
BY DEENA METZGER
The old stories of human relationships with animals can’t be discounted. They are not primitive; they are primal. They reflect insights that came from considerable and elaborate systems of knowledge, intellectual traditions and ways of living that were tried, tested, and found true over many thousands of years and on all continents.
But perhaps the truest story is with the animals themselves because we have found our exemplary ways through them, both in the older world and in the present time, both physically and spiritually. According to the traditions of the Seneca animal society, there were medicine animals in ancient times that entered into relationships with people. The animals themselves taught ceremonies that were to be performed in their names, saying they would provide help for humans if this relationship was kept.Linda Hogan
La Vieja sees them, sees Léonie and Lucas, seated below on what she knows is soft earth, needles and leaves, leaning against one of the sugar pines, the one, as it happens, she favors, though she reminds herself this cannot be as when she descends, as she does each day, she sees another landscape not unlike theirs, but still different. They’ll all see Ponderosa Pines, Douglas Firs, Spruce and Incense Cedars but in different con- figurations. For this moment, it is simple; she looks down and sees them in their territory. Close focus is difficult as La Vieja has trained herself to look for fires—that is her task here—and so she has cultivated distant perspectives but now she is looking closely and her equilibrium is shaky. Also she is looking into another dimension and this requires another focus altogether. It may be for this reason, although she sees them, they do not see her.
Here we are. Two people who did not exist some months ago have come to life. Léonie Augusta because of her relationship with non-humans and Lucas Jay because Léonie asked him if she could help him and he really needed help, his soul was longing for it. We have witnessed their beginnings. These moments, the sperm and egg from which they spring. Later we may fill in a history that conforms to our sense of time but those details are arbitrary and may not be requisite. It is a curious experience to watch something entirely unfamiliar come to be totally unexpectedly, and then realize that although they are newly alive, one’s own life is and will continue to be intertwined with theirs. Nothing will ever be the same. Like a meteor entering the atmosphere from far away in space, beyond one’s imagining and depositing unique life forms that intersect with ours.
Bear had come to see if Lucas is a killer.
These, you understand, are the same two that La Vieja saw at the foot of her Lookout earlier in this text. She witnesses them. She testifies to their existence. Because we are so literal minded as a people, we can only imagine being on the watch for fires, or storms, or invading armies. For danger, not hope. She is not a witness to something that happened, but a witness to an event that is occurring in the moment while creating its own past, the mysterious and unpredictable circumstances from which it arose and became inevitable, affecting everything and everyone, La Vieja and myself, the Writer included, and ultimately, you the reader as well because any and every new element in the world affects us all, everything being connected.
The enormous chasm between what we are learning about the nature of the world and what we can understand, that distance between the two is not a factor to preoccupy us, because once we touch in any way we are eternally connected, and so nothing is separate from anything else, though each one of us is entirely distinct from all others.
Let me suggest that we give up relying on simple versions of cause and effect, or that one thing leads inevitably to another or that we can trace and measure that interaction. Consider resonance instead. That events vibrate continuously, that we are drawn into a vast harmony with which we can make music eternally, unless we continue being afraid of and overwhelmed by beauty. To be in accord with the true nature of the world, we have to yield. In the perfect dance, we lead and follow each other, and then all others simultaneously. That is how the Elephants live. That is their nature. I yielded to them and so I learned yielding. And now Bears. But not dancing bears, not those tortured to dance for some perverted entertainment we seek, oblivious to another’s suffering. That’s not what is meant by dance!
Something is being born. I mean this literally if not chronologically. Léonie is not a fiction, Lucas is not a fiction. I am not, this Writer is not making up a story. Look, it is happening, right there. Their manifestation cannot be dismissed as a mere act of imagination. Not when the Imagination is a real world. I am not willing to say that Léonie is a fiction, nor that Léonie wouldn’t exist without me. Like the proverbial question: Has a tree fallen in the forest if no one has heard it? You bet it has. The question points to our great delusion that humans are the center of the universe and nothing exists without us. This self-centeredness, this narcissism may partly be responsible for the dire fate of the Earth. Would I exist without Léonie? Yes and no. Maybe in another life. But not in this life, because she calls this life, this moment, into being. Does Léonie exist without me, that is, independent of me? Seems very likely except that you would not know about her existence in the same way. As the Writer, I don’t give her life; I give you access to her life. And so I give her access to you.
I presume that is why I have been given the responsibility of recording his as it comes to view. While I am not affecting the action or the story in any way, we are still profoundly interconnected. Is this a mirror of the way life and the natural world really work though we have been given to believe that cause and effect are much more direct and able to be traced?
To what purpose? We can’t answer that because we don’t know where this is going, only what is appearing, only what is being revealed in the way the Przewalski’s horses entered this text a few pages ago, came out of nowhere, a year and a half after it began. It isn’t easy, not only because I don’t understand and don’t know what is coming but because the forms, shapes, sounds and thoughts in this realm don’t translate into words perfectly. And yet it is my task to bring them forth.
Welcome to the mysterious tangle of spiritual intelligence, intent and the unknowable.
I feel compelled to repeat certain words—mysterious, inexplicable, unfathomable, incomprehensible. It is the consequence of standing at this juncture of what is real where events and occurrences are entirely mysterious, inexplicable, unfathomable and incomprehensible, where the nature of reality shifts so entirely that it seems our minds must break from the impact of it. So we shatter and put ourselves together again, but most tentatively and in a different configuration. One we can’t predict.
This is the way it was when Galileo asserted that the Earth was not the center of the universe. That was an earthquake! Or when we had to understand that matter isn’t solid, and that the laws of physics and the laws of quantum mechanics are different.
Now the contemporary tsunami: the human being is not the center of the universe. The human is not the purpose and pinnacle of evolution; there are other species who carry great intelligence, even greater intelligence than ours. They carry spiritual development in ways we cannot imagine, that we lack the capacity to perceive, let alone judge. Maybe humans are the equivalent of a small if awesomely beautiful Earth revolving in a third orbit around a small sun in a universe of billions and billions of such suns. While it may be that life as we know it, that sacred enigma, is rare in the universe, life doesn’t necessarily imply human, or even earthly. There well may be a myriad wondrous forms wiser than we are, that we cannot fathom because we are unable and unwilling to acknowledge what is beyond our benighted and very dangerous selves. Because we are not capable, because our minds have not encompassed reality.
I am reminded of looking down while flying in a small plane at about 12,000 feet across the desert in Namibia and seeing patterns on the Earth that I had first seen in the art of Aboriginal people, which I thought then were abstract images until I realized the artists or dreamers understood things I did not and were rendering the meaning of the landscapes they saw, physical and interior, through their visionary art, however it was that they came to be flying, and so able to see the design. The parallels are so exact, it’s as if the Aboriginal artists have indeed flown across this territory, or that their desert landscapes look enough like this desert that when they fly this is what the spirit world reveals to them. The physical appearance isn’t just happenstance. It develops over millions, billions of years, but physical evolution doesn’t explain the configurations. There are other levels that just begin to reveal themselves to seers like those artists whose work we can admire but cannot yet—I don’t see any evidence we can—understand. We do not see what they see. Layers missing. Levels of understanding.
But meditating upon their art, I understood things I couldn’t say in words. The same for this terrain through which I am flying now. The Aboriginal people will fully understand, no words needed.
I can’t ask La Vieja—it would be rude and intrusive—but I do wonder what La Vieja sees. Is she learning to see with the unique perception of the Aboriginal or other Indigenous peoples?
Two San people accompanied us to Chobe to meet the Ambassador in 2006 and while we, the non-Indigenous people were awed by what transpired, because it was the third time we had witnessed Elephants approaching us with clear intent to transmit something specific of great importance, the San were not impressed. They live in such a world of relationship and interconnection that reveals itself to them consistently and, yes, now also to those of us who are willing to see.
Having just met, Léonie and Lucas are in their own world in a small enclave of possibility, examining each other and their close surroundings, the trees, rocks, wildflowers, but not even those, not yet. Light, yes, the sun will set soon. They are aware of the light, they both seem to move slightly to gather onto themselves what light comes through the trees. They move to the light the way boughs move in the wind.
They arrived in time. Some wind, not much, enough for vitality. A breeze. Soft. Enough to feel and hear the life of the forest. And flashes of blue sky through the slightly moving limbs of the pine and spruce. He is more interested in her than anything in their surroundings, and at this mo- ment particularly her hands. She is, she said, a stone mason.
“I build walls,” she had said. “Free standing. So you can walk around them,” she said. “They often have free-standing arches constructed without mortar. Always without mortar. They serve no purpose except to be themselves. We acquire the stones from wherever we could find them after they had been moved from their original home. My task is to return them to themselves but visibly so they confront us.
“They stand firmly by the way the stones fit onto and so into each other. Sometimes there is earth between them, softening their edges, but mostly, the stones are simply placed, one on another, skin to skin. No mortar to fix them in place while still keeping them apart. Each time a stone is placed, it has to fit perfectly as if it could not be anywhere else, but where it is, upon the stone that has been waiting for it, and between the stones to the side, each perfectly suited to the other.”
She was moving her hands when she spoke as if she was before the wall and placing a stone. She had closed her eyes and bowed her head slightly looking in the dark to see the wall as it might be, scanning the pile of rocks, choosing the one that would go in this place and no other, having been taken once from its original home, she had to find another home for this life that stretched before it. It had been uprooted and she had to set it in place, had to restore and affirm the intrinsic relatedness of the universe that prevails in every quanta of the 7.3 trillion light years of the dimension of the universe. She was building a world.
It is odd, he is thinking, that she would build walls, work with stone, with the unmoving, when it seems she, herself, is always moving slightly, adjusting, affiliate with what is arising, entering, leaving.
“It may not be realistic,” she continued, when she opened her eyes and leaned back upon him again, “but I want to find the stone people homes they will cherish forever. Building a wall, means bringing the stones home. That’s why I do it.” met.
He determined then to be such a home for her though they had just
“The walls you build,” he asked, “standing alone, aren’t they lonely? Or the stones at the top, exposed as they are, aren’t they lonely? Or precarious?”
“They have weather. The foundation has earth and the capping has sky and there are always the birds that land and the squirrels and other creatures who scamper across them. The stones have weather and there is always the company of the trees. They are not alone in the world.”
The two of them had been alone in the world and now, it seemed they were not.
The old woman, La Vieja, looked down upon them, relieved, not because they were inadvertently providing company for her, but relieved that they had found each other and would not be alone. She could feel the energy that was binding them together; it was the force that keeps the planets in their orbits. There was an oppositional force which exuded from them as well that had kept them singular and single until now. It was the force that shielded them from being entangled in the conventional life around them while still always faithful to the central fire around which they circled, always had. La Vieja knew that dance of attraction and repulsion that ultimately became a steady and reliable ellipse around a great sun.
La Vieja was amused that she had come to look far and wand finding the near would have to learn another dance, equally para- doxical. Could she observe without intruding? Was it possible to witness without violating their privacy? At first, she thought this pertained to the two people below but then she realized it pertained even more to the animals. Alone, at a great height away from the ground, she blushed. How quiet she would have to become to view the animals, Bear, Coyote, Bobcat, Cougar, Fox, Squirrel without violating the integrity of their lives. How much quieter so that even Eagle and Owl would be unaware of her. Sure, she wanted to see everything but did she have a right? Did the animals want to be observed by a member of such a voyeuristic species with whom there was no reciprocal exchange?
Colleagues urged me, the Writer, to put up hidden cameras to spy on, to catch the animals at night, or in their nests and dens when she located these. The arrogance and entitlement of two-leggeds. When she had been in Botswana with the Lions who were mating, they had seen her watching them. For a brief moment, when the young lioness had backed off, it seemed that the old man had scanned her and she had, like the lioness, given him everything. He could have leaped upon her and devoured her in one action. As she is a woman, she knew how to open and she did so. In return, he yielded to the lioness who had just risen again on her hungry loins and began to circle him, ravening.
There are two Eucalyptus trees along the patio that I am certain are spirits. One trunk rises up and then bends backwards slightly, displaying her taut belly, one that had never had a child. An equal distance up, she divides into two raised arms. The bark from breast level to elbows has been stripped away and the tree’s body is smooth to the touch. Three feet away is another Eucalyptus with a massive trunk and from her very root, two narrower limbs or legs splay up. The two limbs join the trunk at her craggy groin; the old woman is offering the sweetness of age to the world. These two trees are Maiden and Crone. Is La Vieja willing to be so naked? Am I? We were once the one, the maiden, and now we are the other.
La Vieja kept looking at the two below her, but was no longer hiding herself. She knew them, of course, not the ways they knew themselves yet, but in other ways equally intimate. She has observed them directly as if looking down the hundred feet, approximately, of stairs which lead from her small shelter to the earth floor, where, depending on perspective, another set of stairs might appear leading to another Lookout three hundred miles away.
She had learned to look carefully, to note what was familiar and what slightly awry, so that she would not miss, out of distraction, the small signs that might be of concern, a subtle shading in the sky, a slight shift in color in one place while in another an unexpected haze or a shift of wind apparent in the gentle countermovement of branches and leaves that might indicate heat arising from an illegal campsite or fire. Over time, she had become skilled. It is why she had come here. She wanted, finally, to learn to see. Not daring to consider what use might come of what might be revealed but needing to remain clear-eyed without interpreting. What was the visual equivalent of emptiness? Seeing without naming. Observing without judgment. Seeing in a different ways.
What does that mean, seeing in different ways? How do the lenses of our cosmologies determine what we see? Is it possible to see a fact without looking through a cosmology? Science said yes, but isn’t that the illusion of its perspective? I get up and walk to the southeast corner of this land and turn around slowly, examining everything before me, near and as far as I can see. 360 degrees. My virtual lookout. What do I see when I give myself over to this virtual lookout?
La Vieja pulled herself away from the two below her and traversed the walkway, almost panicked. Fires everywhere. Some were very close, the air dense with smoke, and here and there, toxins rising into the air, black fumes and unnatural colors. If she continued to stare, she would find it hard to breathe and if the firewall moved closer, it would certainly take her down. She had to look away. This is where she was challenged. She was in the process of not looking away, of being resolute in bearing witness. But would anything come from her succumbing to the heat? No, she decided. It would bring the fire closer and much more than her life would be endangered. Yet, she did not rush to call the Rangers.
She cast her gaze further as if a telescope aimed at the sky, the farther away she looked, the further away in time. The fires weren’t all current. Some were fires of the last years, Paradise, Australia, the Amazon, Chernobyl, Fukushima were still burning, still smoldering though common sense (another point of view) said they were out and need not call our attention when indeed she had resolved never to look away.
And then the question came to her: was it possible to put out the fires which were still burning in the past because the causes had never been addressed?
She scanned all the directions again, aware that she had successfully taught herself to look far, farther than she imagined it was possible to see. Some of the fires were not from the past, some were burning in the future, but their light hadn’t reached us yet. She could see far enough to perceive them but she had no idea yet and might never know whom to call or how to begin to extinguish them, let alone prevent them from being ignited in the first place. Which, unknowingly, had she set?
La Vieja looked from the two below her to the fires and back again and to the fires again. The movement prevented her from being dazed by despair. She needed to know she could look back to that view even as now she scanned the green forest around her where there was at this moment no sign of danger, and then she looked below and saw the familiar footing of her Lookout. Then again, a slight shift, not a filmic dissolve but so rapid a substitution of another reality it was seamless, and there they were again, perhaps only one hundred and fifty feet away, still as the planets in the night sky, breathing in and out each other’s breaths permeated by the breath of the trees, listening, like she was, to merge with them, listening for the Bears.
A film of a tribal village had been made by an anthropologist who had shown it to the tribespeople. The tribal observers had not been able to “see” the chickens who were pecking in the dust though they saw them perfectly when among them. They were not trained to differentiate the pixels in the ways Westerners are trained. The images were merely images, two dimensional moving shapes which interested them not at all. Representations were not real. What then, the anthropologist wondered, about their art? He would have had to penetrate far more deeply into the culture, would have had to take on another mind or understanding, to experience the reality of the sacred images they carved and painted. He and his cololeagues had been cautioned against, “going native.” Although participatory observation was encouraged, it was to assure those studied of the sincerity of the scientist, it was never intended for the anthropologist to fully accept the world view of the other and live accordingly. Objective observation was the goal, subjective experience the means. The anthropologists must always hold themselves apart. The film proved to the tribespeople how remote the filmmaker was from reality. The image of the chicken was not a sacred image and so it was not real and so it did not exist. How much the Western anthropologist missed by his remove. The tribespeople would not explain what they did see because the anthropologist was the one unable to see. It was the anthropologist who could not organize “the data” to perceive what was real. The anthropologist could not speak the tribal language as a Native and the English language could not hold perceptions foreign to it.
“The image of the chicken was not a sacred image and so it was not real…” La Vieja lifted her eyes from the two below her and then back to them. Something shifted as she changed her focus. Shifted because, it seemed to her she was expecting the shift. But what if she moved her gaze without a change in concentration or tone? What if she lavished the same interest on the Pine that they were leaning against as upon them, as if it were an extension of them, one of their limbs? The tree also urged her heart to open the way it opened in their presence. She stilled herself as best she could. She was not contriving this response: what if the sincere expression of the sensation of love onto the tree sustained it? What if she, bathing the future with her great love for the land, quenched the future fires?
She could do so ritually because it was true in her. There might not be much in her that was entirely reliable, but her love for these great beings, this landscape, was true.
It felt so heady, though it was not of the mind but of the heart. Indigenous people thought with the heart but now she was seeing through the lens of the heart as well. Time then to close her eyes. To stop. To rest.
She believed she had seen the two before, probably in her imagination because they were so familiar to her and she knew their names and details of their lives, confirmed by the conversations with each other which La Vieja was overhearing. She recognized their stories, imprints more telling than fingerprints.
Now they were here. Just below. Embodied in all ways. She can almost touch them. For a moment as she gazed at them, they tensed a little with anticipation and their muscles tightened, their bodies taut in expectation of the others coming, the Bears, they hoped.
Turning and turning, walking, from east to west, from dawn to nightfall, from then to now, round and round the boardwalk as if walking the rotations around the sun, walking time and space, hoping the momentum, the passage from past to present, might help her reach the deep connection from which wisdom might arise. The two appeared below her, albeit in an- other geography, another time, another dimension. She had to keep her fo- cus, the ongoing inquiry, her desperate and perhaps naïve assumption that if she kept asking questions, kept looking farther and farther, further and further, where both knowledge and the past, even the far past resided as one, she would get an answer or a direction. That ancestors would answer, whether it was a short-faced Bear who 11,000 years ago might have walked exactly where the Lookout is now, or her own equally unknown great- great-grandmother, someone or another from the other side to guide her, some voice, some communication beyond herself would finally arrive, some explosion to illuminate these times, like light arriving finally from the ring of fire we call the Big Bang, our own birth throes. Wisdom. Might she hope for wisdom?
They had not built a fire because the continuing and intensifying fire seasons prohibited what had been totally acceptable when Léonie was a child. Her father had built the fire as soon as they had arrived at their hideaway. She stayed by it after he and her mother had withdrawn to their tent. Her father trusted her to be attentive even when she was quite young. The Bears agreed the fire pits indicated a meeting place for Bears and child.
Léonie and Lucas will build a fire later in the cabin woodstove but it was not one the Bears would join in the way Léonie always shared a fire in her dreams. Without a fire, what would draw them? How would they know she was returning to them, now and here? She sniffed, snuggled more deeply into Lucas, rubbed against the roughness of his red and black plaid wool shirt, differentiating his scent from the surrounding scents, waiting for the pungent odor like no other, praying they would come before it was dark. La Vieja began this vigil with them, looking into the woods for what life might be there. No matter how dark it gets, La Vieja could see them, curious that it was this vision that was given to her during this vigil.
The Bear sensing Léonie and Lucas upwind of him but down the slope moves toward their Lookout. He is examining the stairs, establishing the fact of them. He knows humans can’t climb the way he does and are con- tinuously finding ways to augment their biological limitations. He scratches his back against the nearby sugar pine, not honey, but sweet enough, then turns swiftly and is up the trunk, up, swift to the branches which lean out to the deck and settles into the crook, observing.
They look out from this shelter, he understands, for he has often been in, has taken on their body mind, or if not theirs specifically yet, La Vieja’s, and if not hers, many others, even former residents in this cabin. His small brown eyes crinkle and his black stub nose crinkles; sight and smell often fuse for him into a single way of knowing. Why distinguish them? He can scent the two from below and the odor from the cabin verifies them.
From this perch, he can also smell the stream that has carved the valley below, her tireless pursuit of her beloved river that likewise rushes toward the distant, irresistible salt tang, the current that rises from the sea seeking the warming, sundrenched earth. One wind becomes the other, the salt laden wind sinks as it crosses the land and then rises on the exhale of trees to slide down again to the waters, a mixture, a little twirl, invisible turbulence or the spout of a whale bellowing, and then the dissolve into the sea and beginning again. Wind, rising and falling, in land and offshore, warm and cooling, fierce and gentle, a field of actions interpenetrating and dispersing, distinction without separation. Everything is in motion, that is what life is, even the boulders he lies on when he wants to warm himself in the sun, or those which have been formed into the cave he enters to sleep for a winter, are all still in movement, as are even the stones, though so slowly a human will miss it, but he doesn’t. Everything in motion, every- thing. As long as the humans aren’t there, all is well. As long as the humans aren’t there now or later. He is always seeking exceptions as they are so numerous.
He looks in every direction. But he knows this is no way to see, or for him to see in the manner the humans call seeing; assuming that the visual yields the most significant understanding is remote for him. So much can occur, is occurring between where he is cradled in the tree and the stream he senses and beyond, a world of beings, multitudes in dynamic interconnection, no human being can take it in. The humans must ignore these exchanges for if they were aware of each, they would explode, for it would mean carrying the entire universe, actively, at once. They cannot, will not open to it. Although his way is simple, it is sufficient. Even as sight and smell inform him, what he knows best at this moment is tree, because he knows her, this moment, with his entire being. He examines the deck, the faux timber, and the distorted and altered scents that arise from it. Then another scent rises and descends the tree, each motion releasing an aroma as if conversational. His touch, her response. The two humans are seated a short lope from him and he will loop around a good distance and approach them from the east. They are waiting for him; they are attuned to the proper etiquette to encounter the wild. Him.
Léonie is leaning back into Lucas and he is settling against the sugar pine so that the Bear senses he has the freedom to approach or not as he wishes. As he, the Bear, wishes. They consciously open to his choice and this reception exudes from them like an aroma so that even La Vieja can smell it a hundred or more feet away.
Soon the Bear will approach and this is what will occur. Or the Bear approached and this is what occurred. La Vieja won’t reveal what has or will occur while it is occurring. She would not dare to influence this event in any way. Having said this, it is best if we learn what happened after the fact.
Imagine how quietly he walked that he was suddenly before them, standing erect, nine feet tall, without either of them, or La Vieja, having heard him. That is an awesome height to confront. Lucas tightened his fin- gers on Léonie’s arms inadvertently but she remained still because the mo- ment Bear appeared, she fell into the dream realm and was calmed by memory and experience. Lucas doesn’t have such an experience and further, he understood instantly that Bear was not here for Léonie, he was here to discern who Lucas is. He had smelled the two of them from many miles away. From the moment, they arrived, he smelled them. And La Vieja? Of course, he smelled her in the other realm that she inhabits. No animal has a better sense of smell than a Bear. So let’s be conservative, Bear smelled them when they were within 20 miles of him because they had the windows of their car open. This only gives us distance. It doesn’t give us time.
Bear had come to see if Lucas is a killer. He already knew Lucas didn’t have a gun or a hunting rifle in his car. He would have known immediately, by odor and intuition and would never have approached, but rather sounded the alarm to all the Bears in the vicinity, especially the female Bear who is currently eating and eating because she is carrying his cubs and needs to put on lots of weight to support the three of them in the winter when they will be born while she hibernates. At some point he may compete with the grown males, but not now. Now he wants his gene pool in the world. It is robust.
Bear wanted to know if Lucas has ever carried a rifle. Not whether he has one now, whether he has ever carried a rifle. He has to smell back forty years. A Polar bear can track a scent forty miles but this Black Bear has to track back forty years. He isn’t concerned about Léonie, she is a woman and she is a dreamer. But Lucas is a man. A two-legged male. He will have to prove himself. Bear stood his full height, rubbing his back against the closest pine. Then he turned and ran his claws down the bark of the tree, marking it. If Lucas used guns, Bear intended to mark him. This is 2020. Men are exceedingly dangerous. Trustworthiness needs to be proven again and again, and from Bear’s point of view, is never certain.
Then Bear perceived something odd. He put his nose into the wind, but that was not the source of the scent. He couldn’t place it because it wasn’t from this geography but it wasn’t alien either—it was distant, it came from miles away. Even a thousand miles away and many decades earlier. It didn’t overpower Lucas’ scent, but it was a portion of it. Old. Passed on. Female. Had he spoken English, Bear would have said Mexico, then pine nuts, prickly pear, madrone, yucca. He began to ease. It was an old scent, several hundred years old. The Bear couldn’t know what has occurred since, and Lucas probably didn’t know either. But Lucas came from this hemisphere. He was born here as were his mother’s mothers and fathers centuries before the invasion. The Bear dropped to all fours. Lucas passed his scrutiny. Thank his ancestors for this.
Bear looked over at Léonie who did not dare make eye contact, knowing she was in his sight and could hide nothing from him. He could see her almost as well as he could smell her. There was nothing she could hide from him. She went directly back into the dream where she had sat next to the male Bear. He would be able to track her there as well as here and it would protect her. She had fallen onto the mother Bear’s body but she had sat erect and cautious next to the male Bear. As she did this moment. In this moment and in the dream, simultaneously. Not worried but not casual about this encounter. She was being scrutinized by a high intelligence whose every sense was extremely sensitive—his awareness from every per- spective far more highly developed than hers. It wasn’t simply that he could smell her but he understood her from her various and varying scents. Or that he could see her precisely, had far better vision than she did, or that he could hear her so well, he could interpret each of her breaths, even from a distance. It wasn’t only that his senses were so very refined and developed, like microscopes, telescopes, finely tuned instruments, it was more the ways he processed the information that he had received, until he felt con- fident that he could make a valid assessment of how Léonie would affect Bear’s present and future. He had progeny, after all. He’d better have prog- eny. There were two possibilities he was considering: these two could sustain his species’ future, or they could kill it. These two were allies or murderers. Only these two possibilities? Yes, only these two!
The Bear perceived Léonie entirely, everything about her now, everything, and her past, as with Lucas, and his origins and so her origins. She knew she didn’t comprehend him. Her task was to acknowledge this in all ways. There was nothing she could keep secret and so she opened. Even Lucas felt the flood of revelation as it passed by him to the Bear. He caught the wave of it. The full scent of woman’s heart and a wisp of four-legged intelligence flooded his entire being. She would want reciprocity from Lucas, would want him to open to her so fully, but the presence of Bear would not be there to help him yield. He would have to learn the means alone.
La Negra y Blanca
BY DEENA METZGER
1492 began a history of torture in Europe and in the Americas. Victor named it the Unfinished Conquest. He didn’t escape it. He probably always knew he would be its victim. He watched it come at him from all sides. If he had a prayer, it might have been that his writing would be sufficiently successful to cast him as one of the final victims. We did not know or understand what he knew. It seemed to us that there was a great divide between his work in Guatemala and his connection with his past and his Sephardic roots. What he had been trying to tell us was that they were the same. The conquest had merely cut down another pear tree but this time in Guatemala. When he died, we didn’t understand that he had become just another victim of an unending Conquest. What was acknowledged was that anxiety, political anxiety, can raise blood pressure and as he hated his meds and often refused them, he had fallen victim but to his own recalcitrance.
But when people asked: “How is your blood pressure?” You would answer, “Rios Montt.”
Non-compliant is a term suited to blaming victims. Victims are blamed for the suffering others contend they should have been able to avoid or overcome. We called his torture, a stroke, and afterwards many of his friends chastised him for the delusion that he could control his blood pressure with his mind, or for preferring his mind as he knew it, for being resistant, for not recognizing medical authority, for being unwilling to endure side-effects, for being naïve and choosing inadequate and untested natural remedies, for being stubborn, for taking unnecessary risks. For choosing his way of suffering and its consequences in lieu of the medically prescribed way of suffering – side effects – and their consequences. His friends had predicated their lives on the belief that could define and choose their destiny, that they had the right, that they could and should outwit death at a young age, that death, at the height of one’s vitality might be a sign of an inner failing. Victor had betrayed them.
Perhaps the projection of our own concerns for our own lives, being marooned in the defining territory of our own anxieties, allowed us to miss the threat that was coming toward him. Such threats didn’t exist in our lives. They belonged to other lives and other countries. We read about them. We were responsible; we watched the news. We watched serious movies on such subjects.
The privilege of an expanding universe. Ease, privilege, power created the ever increasing space between ourselves and our fears, between ourselves and danger to us. Then our universe reached its zenith or its nadir, choose as you will, and began contracting. We were living closer, increasingly, to what we feared. But we didn’t know it yet. Blue, an expanding universe, had turned to red, contraction. We were color blind to that transformation.
Those who may have known something of the crises firsthand, buried alarm the way one buries toxic waste. If someone other than Victor testified, issued warnings, we responded as one does to literature. Another country we can enter but also leave at will. Close the book.
I say we. I didn’t want to look away. And…I didn’t know I was looking away.
We don’t know what injured Victor. Medical diagnosis can’t reconstitute his life. Maybe it was a direct physical attack by other men on a lone man swimming in the lake at the end of the day when the darkening sky and shadows merge so that all things, beings, actions, motives can be hidden. Or maybe it was brujerîa, an invisible attack, launched by the current agents of the conquest, or launched five hundred years ago and still traveling.
What was the truth of his affliction and death? He could never say. He couldn’t speak of it having spent his lifetime seeking it out. Twenty years earlier, a dream had taught me that gaining information, the alleged purpose of torture, is actually a means of silencing a population. Of course, Victor had helped me understand the dream and the reality it described. We both hoped we would never yield to being silenced though we didn’t pretend we could possibly know what it was like to be dismembered, one limb at a time, or thrown into a pit or forced into a latrine with rats while the guards laughed at our confinement, at our inability to escape, at our bellowing and crying out.
When he was found, he was lying, face down, unconscious on the small stretch of sand alongside the lakeshore. He had no papers on him. He was identified days later when the police were able to match the seemingly abandoned locked car in the parking lot to the unknown man in the hospital. The doctors said, he would never speak and never walk again. Massive stroke, they said. They did not believe he would survive, and no one suspected that violence had been done to him. The causes they were seeking were directly related to the treatment, as if the ultimate causes were unrelated to his prognosis and so were best categorized as acts of God. This is the kind of understanding that sits best with unbelievers.
But Victor had learned about the gods in the God house, drinking Balché with Chan Ki’n the Lacandon elder whose story he told in The Last Lords of Palenque, and though he knew the gods do not protect us from suffering, as it seems the gods had not been able, or authorized, were unwilling or without desire to save the Lacandon or the esteemed Chan K’in, even the great mahogany trees or the milpa unless … unless … we…? Even so, Victor also knew the gods do not authorize the violence attributed to them by so many of their alleged followers.
We enter thus into the eye of the mystery. What are we called to understand and become? If Chan Ki’n played his part and Victor played his, what parts are we being called to play in this game that is so much greater than the sum of the parts and the players?
I want to sit down again with the physicians who were attending Victor and were drawn ineluctably into the circle of concern that surrounded him and our determination that he would live, that he would walk, that he would speak. We got two out of three. It was not enough. What we got was the exquisite on-going torture. We got the pit. We got the tongue cut out. In retrospect, not anything we could characterize as victory or healing. I want to sit down with the physicians and ask them to backtrack and begin again. I want to say, you didn’t have the diagnosis right. The direct cause of his affliction was the Conquest. Now, what treatments will you prescribe? How can you call yourself a physician, if you don’t have a protocol for the Conquest?
A Rain of Nightbirds
BY DEENA METZGER
STONE HEAPS OF THE NCHE-WANA. Long time ago, Indian boys were sent to the mountains by their father, or next of kin. Maybe it is an old man, a good hunter, a great warrior or medicine, who sent the boy. The boy stays two or three nights in a lonely place. He must not drink water he must not eat food. He must pray and call on the Ruling Spirit. He must not sleep, but after a time he will fall down and sleep. He then sleeps; hears strange things. The boy piles up stones so that his people will know that he has been there. Perhaps such are the stone heaps you saw on the summit of the boulders along the nChe-wana.
Heard from Joe Tuckaho, Nez Perce, on July 5th, 1922
THOSE STONE HEAPS. Those stone heaps you ask about! They are made this way. Years ago, the old Indians would send their children, their little boys when about ten and twelve years old, to the mountains to stay seven days and seven nights. The boy made a pile of stones .... Sometimes there is an old man who has lost all his people. He feels lonely; he is sad. He goes up and down the mountain some- where. He builds up stones. He sits there and cries for he is alone in the world. In this way were many of those stone-heaps made. The white man should not tear them down.
Heard from Tom Hill, warrior of the Nez Perce War of 1877 on July 5th, 1911
Autumn 2007. Terrence Green was at the foot of a mountain, of Wy’east, Mt. Hood. He was approaching the trail his ancestors had used for hundreds, perhaps thousands of years to pray, make offerings and do ceremony. He had not understood when he set out running from the office and jumping into his truck, taking off without a suitcase, what was driving him. He had his wallet, boots, moccasins, down vest, sweater, jacket, sunglasses. He did not take his computer. He had a pen and paper. He had his cell phone but turned it off. He had wanted to leave it behind but he didn’t have absolute confidence in his vehicle. He was not naked but close enough by contemporary standards. He had an early copy of the IPCC report that had disturbed him so.
He had begun to read the report at home and then continued in his office. He came to a small paragraph among the more than 2,000 pages of the report and he stopped reading for a while and then continued to the end – altered. But it was not sufficient; he had to read that paragraph away from his office, away from brick, glass and steel. He had to read it on the land in order to absorb its implications. The content was not surprising, its inclusion was.
He read, “9.6.2 Indigenous knowledge systems. The term ‘indigenous knowledge’ is used to describe the knowledge systems developed by a community as opposed to the scientific knowledge that is generally referred to as ‘modern’ knowledge (Ajibade, 2003). Indigenous knowledge is the basis for local level decision making in many rural communities. It has value not only for the culture in which it evolves, but also for scientists and planners striving to improve conditions in rural localities. Incorporating Indigenous knowledge into climate change policies can lead to the development of effective adaptation strategies that are cost-effective, participatory and sustainable. (Robinson and Herbert, 2001).”
Without planning, he had come to this Mountain. Because it was a sacred place.
He had to read it as an Indigenous man, not as a scientist. He had never expected to find these references in an IPPC Assessment Report. Two worlds, the one into which he had been born, and the one that opposed it, but had kidnapped him, slammed into each other. He stood very still for a long time and then he began running, but not as a man running away, though he was running from his office, from the building, from a way of thinking and acting that he’d had to take on and fit into, from a mind and a style that had penetrated into his core like a poison, the way its poisoned breath, acid rain, penetrated into the leaves and roots of living beings who, unable to escape, tried to open to it even more in order to take in and separate its elements, in order to return it to its formerly neutral elements.
He was moving fast and steadily, as he had learned as a child. Running was memory. It was so steady, it could go on for hours or even days. The Earth turned and the people ran on it, turning with it. He almost ran past his truck, which he chose to park in the furthest outside lot avoiding the fumes of the parking structures. If he were not in an urban area, he might have deluded himself that it was possible to run from where he was to where he needed to go now. Then he was on the road, driving as if he were running. He did not call anyone to say he would be gone. He did not call Sandra from the road. He just went.
At home, Sandra had watched him carefully as he was first reading the report. He paled, his eyes filled, he bit his lip. They had both known what would be in it, as well as how extremely it would be tempered to make it acceptable, having several colleagues who were working on various United Nations committees: Climate change is real and humans are responsible. Beneath the neutral and formal scientific language was another message that he and Sandra and certainly many others recognized. Our situation is grave. The damage is most probably irreversible. Unless … all life is doomed.
The goal of the report was to confirm what was obvious in order to inform those, particularly in government, who needed such confirmation to enact change, and those who would not encompass the new reality without such evidence, and to challenge the willfully ignorant but powerful who were devoted only to pursuing their own financial goals. At the same time it was necessary to prevent worldwide panic.
Terrence’s people were familiar with meeting the worst contingencies in council and so with awareness. He did not find this resilience outside Indigenous communities in part, he thought, because non-Indigenous people were no longer living in vital and interdependent communities. The global transition from we to I was almost complete. The world to which he had been exiled was based on maintaining a state of fear and its members were constrained from acting together on their own behalf. He understood that despite being marginalized, Indigenous people had the ability and willingness to assess the world situation precisely – they were also the ones no one heeded. Instead, they would learn from the news that what they had long known was happening had been confirmed by science. Despite having been ignored, they would still retreat to the long house, pray through the night, and sit in council in the day. What new role might open to them on behalf of the Earth?
Terrence imagined trying to call such a council at the university. The dean would have to consider a budget. Why did he need a budget and administrative approval to take an action on behalf of the planet? It was all hopeless. Hopeless, Terrence realized, should not be in his vocabulary. Hopeless was not a word his grandfather would use. Hopeless does not coexist with the spirits. Nor does hopeful. Hope in any form turns us toward ourselves. “You do what you are called to do,” his grandfather had instructed him. “Those other folk are always thinking about what they are going to get out of it.”
Not hopeless, but still aware the world could end. Terrence struggled against the vortex of emptiness that was threatening to draw him down into parallel dimensions of subterranean oceans and fires. He could drown or burn. He preferred the exquisite pain of the auto-da-fé. He did not intend to privilege his own death. If the Earth was going to burn, he would burn with her.
Glancing over at Sandra, he saw the set of her jaw, her fingers trembling slightly as she turned the pages. They were a council of two. It would have to be sufficient.
Terrence had to read every word in order to fulfill his academic responsibilities and between every line to know what he had to know. Sandra was freer to choose which of the various panels she would read. They sat down to their tasks while each knew that the abstract filter of scientific language would not be sufficient to remove the implicit anguish and horror of knowing they were, humanity was, bringing the great and wild beauty that is planet Earth to an end. There had never been an evil as great as that which has been attacking all the living beings of Earth, and the two knew, that if only by the lives they lived, they were complicit. Their eyes continued to meet over the texts, then they lowered them and turned the pages.
He read as long as he could. Toward dawn he sat down in the north, hoping the ancestors would speak to him. They didn’t. Then he got up and went to the office. He stood still looking out the window. This was not unusual for him, except he was standing there a very long time. Then he ran. Then he fled. Then he went forward.
In his tradition, in the past, one did not have to “telephone” and say one was going on a journey. The community would have known when the person knew. One did not need to send a runner. One did not need to send out emails. One did not need to leave a vacation message on a phone machine. He would be gone and the community would understand that he had left to find what could only be found alone and they would wait patiently for his return, praying for him. Recognizing he had to leave was a simultaneous event for the person and the community. That is just the way it was. Not fleeing. No foul play. A mission. Going on one’s way. Halfway to his destination, he understood what he was doing differently. He was running away from the world he had inhabited and he was running toward.
He did not turn on the radio as he drove. Words repeated in his head and he couldn’t clear them.
“Traditional Indigenous Knowledge.
“Traditional Indigenous Knowledge and Wisdom.
“Traditional Indigenous Knowledge.
“Traditional Indigenous Knowledge and Wisdom.
“Traditional Indigenous ….”
They repeated, a chant, until he could no longer understand the words or how the world was vanishing, was going extinct. And so much beauty and wisdom with it.
And so he went on. Miles and miles. Light fell and night rose and light rose and night fell. As he had been trained, he went without sleep. Then he was at the river. Then he turned south again and east.
“Volcano,” he murmured at the very first glimpse of the mountain from the twisting road, as if he could erase the feelings that were rising in him, churning the way the concealed molten rock was churning under the Earth, and replace them with facts and information, as if lecturing to undergraduate students in Geology 101. He had taught such a course several times even though it was not his field, filling in for another professor. But the words defining and describing a volcano that would have followed in a class didn’t follow.
Reducing it as science does would be a violation. He came to the place he intended to leave his truck. The truck would be visible but not prominent. He could disappear without vanishing entirely.
Then he walked. He did not allow himself to describe the path even to himself. His steps had to be invisible so there would be no chance of the way being known by anyone except his Grandfather and Grand Uncle who were on the other side.
Finally, he was at the foot of the mountain having come here like a man on fire, exploring. Then, like a man emerging from a fog, remembering.
He came to the place of vision that he recognized, that he had known as a young boy, and so he stopped.
“Snow” and “Fire,” he whispered to himself as he looked at the mountain he was remembering from childhood. “Mountain.” He corrected himself, “Mountain.” Yes, he had come here as a boy with his grandfather and his father’s uncle. His grandfather had not spoken of Terrence’s father, had not spoken of his own son then. Too many young Native men had died young or disappeared or suffered unbearable distortions of body and soul in the dark times. Still, the line of fathers behind Terrence, straight as the cedars from which they carved the guardian spirits of the land, was coming into focus. And, maybe, his own father, so long on the other side, was standing with them.
“Never forget this,” his father’s uncle had said, but his grandfather had said nothing, knowing the boy would have to forget because he would be sent away on behalf of the people. Would this moment come back to him at a critical point in his life? Whether Terrence would recognize it and remember would matter.
Only the Mountain itself, its presence on the landscape, that moment with Grandfather and Uncle on the mountain, the living imprint of ceremony performed upon Wy’east for thousands of years, was given to him to treasure and protect. Had he remembered? He had repressed it. It had slipped out of sight and was buried under the field of rubble formed by the debris and preoccupations of the dominant culture that had been claiming him.
If he were fortunate, if he had, wittingly or unwittingly prepared for this moment, if he was remembering, then it was like the sharpened bone with which a man would pierce his own flesh so that he could hang from the tree of the world and gain … what would he gain? Gain was not the issue. What would be the offering? In his mind, he thrust the bone of memory through his chest wall and wisdom and despair poured through him like blood.
His grandfather had known that they were entering into the darkest time of forgetting, erasure and eradication. Genocide of body, mind and soul. His grandfather had known the great pain. Foreknowledge did not prevent disaster. Understanding did not diminish the agony. They had fought for their land and lost. Losing was not the tragedy, losing to the ways of the white men was the tragedy. Had they lost the land to another tribe, it would not have destroyed their ways of life, would not have damaged the Earth. But having to fight the white men for the land was defeat from the beginning. Having to use weapons that were not their own, that were not coordinated with their sacred lives, undermined them and damaged the Earth beyond redemption. Having to fight, having to fight in the way they were required to fight, for the reasons they had to fight, being forced by war to think of land as property that could be stolen or conquered, was an anathema, but they fought anyway because they had to stand for the land. “I left my land on my own,” he told Mountain as he stood at its feet. “They didn’t have to come and get me by force. I went on my own.
“I was asked to go, it was assumed it would be of benefit, and I agreed. My acquiescence became my agreement, my choice.”
He lowered his eyes, but truth required him to look forward.
He wanted to speak truthfully aloud. Without planning, he had come to this Mountain. Because it was a sacred place. Because he would know what had to be known here. An urgency such as he had never known had brought him.
He had his braid. He still had that, though he had been accused of sentimentality or display for keeping it. It had become his silent mnemonic. Once Sandra had offered to braid it for him and the chill of the forbidden went through him though her intentions were only loving. She had not understood the grimace of violation or loathing that had transformed his face beyond his own recognition. He had turned away from her, gone outside, relocated himself in his own heart and slowly, carefully, twisted red cloth into so tight a braid that he was aware of the pull on his scalp each time he moved his head.
He and she understood afterwards that like so many Indigenous peoples, he lived within a system of holy taboos that provided order in a chaotic world. For some members of Western culture, breaking taboos was exhilarating. He felt the wisdom of acquiescing.
“Mountain,” he repeated, not in English, but in his original language. He spoke the sacred name as if he had never seen such a phenomenon before and also as if he remembered every detail of the time he had been brought here. Then he was on his knees, the lifeblood pounding heatedly in his body as his legs chilled from the frozen earth. He was on his knees, he was prone, his head was on the ground, he was weeping. Then he stood up as he had been taught, barefoot now. He looked around him and found stones and piled them up so he would remember that he had been here. As he remembered what his elders had known, he straightened up and looked Mountain in the eye. Steady. Steady ….
He had left all his identification in the truck. It would not be appropriate to come to this place with the dog tags of the alien world in which he lived. He had been recruited to live among the enemy on behalf of the land. Coming home to the Mountain, he had to return as himself. With every step, he had stripped himself of the acquired identity. What his Grandfather had thought might come to be; Terrence knew this as he revealed his face before the Mountain.
Afternoon. Sunset. Night. Moon rise. Starlight reflecting off the snowy peak. The Mountain saw him and he continued standing, looking at the Mountain.
He was in sacred time and sacred space. Even history ceased to exist. Everyone and everything vanished from his sight. Finally, he had arrived.
Sandra stirred restlessly in the tent when Terrence did not return from the University. His teaching assistant checked and saw Terrence’s truck was not in its usual space and a parking attendant searched the area and attested that it was not in the lot or anywhere on campus.
They had both been reading the IPCC report and he had taken his volume with him when he went to the University. She could imagine that he had gone off to mourn and to pray. To honor that possibility, she stayed in the tent and read the report in more detail than she might have otherwise. She needed to share his ordeal. His ordeal? She was embarrassed to have thought she wasn’t completely responsible. Let the ordeal be her form of prayer.
After two days, she lost the connection with him. Then she was a stranger in the tent, an intruder.
She was of the people who had created the Anthropocene, which some dated from the Industrial Revolution, and others calculated it from the Holocene, the Neolithic, the start of agriculture. Agriculture meant stores and property. Stores and property created power. Power meant fortification. Fortifications meant hierarchy. Property, power, fortification, hierarchy, conquest, war – the present.
Or it was dated differently: to the end of the eighteenth century and the beginning of the Industrial Revolution, the moment of James Watt’s newly invented steam engine and the enormous expansion in the use of fossil fuels. No matter the cause or the time. It was here with its consequences.
She knew her people were culpable while his people and the Earth were among the victims. Now he had bonded with her, the other. He was carrying her within him, the way, inevitably, he carried his mother inside. He could not refuse them though it might also be a betrayal of history and his entire life to be one with them. Terrence and Sandra carried the same grief for the Earth and these times; they were both reeling from it. And they each carried different grief. The first had bonded them until this moment and now it seemed it was tearing them apart.
She couldn’t stay here a moment longer. Looking around at her things so carefully placed in the space, she shuddered as if they had been strewn. Her thoughts stormed in her mind, the winds of doubt blasted her. She gathered up as much as she could in her arms and fled also.
When she arrived at her house, she brought everything inside, including her pail of earth, as if she would settle down here again, to fit into an old life as if she had never left. She opened all the windows. She still owned the house. She had not prepared it for sale. It had been their intention to sell – certainly they did not need so many houses, though they were concerned that the land would fall victim to developers. They were considering the options, how to restore the land to its own autonomy but neither she nor he had wanted to be preoccupied with real estate when they were just beginning to know each other. So as it was still hers, she could slip in as if returning from an assignment, from the Arctic or Africa. Or something more casual, a site visit to the development where she was consulting.
But she no longer belonged in this house. She was in limbo. It was not that she had been away, it was that she had entered another life. The house did not belong to her anymore or, rather, she did not belong to it. She was from somewhere else that was disappearing too. She paced the circular deck looking in the windows. Then she came into the house and circumambulated it similarly from within. It wasn’t as if she hadn’t been here recently, she had, but like a sojourner to an outpost. Now, supposedly, she was home again. The furniture was unfamiliar. She examined the curved andirons that were still in the fireplace, the fireplace tools that seemed ornate now, the bellows, the carved box that held firewood. They had been created with fashion in mind, with appearance. She had wanted a house that looked simple, not a simple dwelling.
Terrence had used a wood bench when he sat and stared into the fire. Terrence had thrown a blanket across a wood box so she could sit down next to him and stare into the fire. That had become natural and comfortable while the artifacts, the appliances that furnished her house, all seemed alien. They seemed to have a will of their own, calling attention to themselves. The house was declaring itself to her as worthy of a magazine display on simplicity. Four dimensions folded into two. She was being pressed into a given shape by the corners and angles of her possessions. Possessions. In the last months, the idea of possessions had left her. The spaces in between took her attention, as if she could see both time and space without concern for the events or objects that might occupy them. Earth had been her element, but Terrence had introduced her to motion, the elements of wind, water and fire. She had once wanted a solid house, a well-built house, dependable. A signature house. A house with things. Not many things, but things nevertheless. Signature things.
That was before she met Terrence. Thoughts of him began to assault her and she forced them away. She was not to fix him, to capture him, even in her mind. Now she was in the dissolve, the way one dimension morphs into another. Terrence had disappeared. Maybe he had shapeshifted. Maybe he had become wind. Maybe he had never been anything else. A storm had come and blown away her life. She turned and turned in the circle, but when she realized she was spiraling down into dread and fear, she stopped in her office, picked up the phone and called her father. It would not take him long to join her; he’d had no need to ask any questions over the phone.
While waiting for him to join her, Sandra went onto the roof and then onto the land. There, finally, among the trees, she settled down. Walking, well, not really walking, but pacing and then slowing down, then sliding down against a tree looking north because she felt he had gone in the direction of his people, land and ancestors, she found calm within herself. There was still a thread between them, thin though it was. She imagined what it might feel like for a spider to spin silk from the spinnerets on her abdomen and to let the thread waft in the faintest breeze, just a hint of wind, to attach where it must, there, wherever he was.
The palms of her hands flat on the Earth, looking up at the trees she had known so well, she was filled with the mystery of here and there. Had she abandoned this land in her rush to be with a human? This land and the land where she had been with Terrence, and Terrence, wherever he was, the thin silk of being emerging from her, honing in and attaching to him so the web could be woven that connected them. Crows flew into the pine and cawed. She had forgotten them. Her neighbors. She had been confused by notions of roads, miles, boundaries, highway markers, zones and designations, houses, property, real estate, but the true connections had never been interrupted or severed. The crows did not live in the bounded world. Her connection was with a terrain not a parcel and she shared that terrain with others. Then a raven entered the field uttering the round sound and hollow mating call that assured her that there would be others. The land enhanced and maintained by the presence of all the others; it could not exist without them.
Threads emerged from her abdomen and fluttered in the currents as they connected here and there, the web illuminated by the sun, flickered in and out of visibility as it stretched from a sycamore in the streamed by their tent to the branches above Sandra’s head to Terrence wherever he was now. The tires from John’s car crunched over the gravel in front of the house. Sandra got up so carefully not to impair the weaving that had gathered her in.
Dawn.
Terrence Green turned around to walk the seven miles back to his truck.
Terrence walked back from the Mountain with the same care with which he had approached the place of ceremony. His steps were heavy; he was carrying the Mountain with him. Until this moment, he had been a man of wind. It had allowed him to move the way he had, to leave one place for another. To be fleet footed. But now he, as others before him, would have to carry more than one spirit. Sometimes when his people were being initiated, they would be asked to carry the world. When one is asked, one cannot refuse. He remembered that Mountain had come when he was caring for Sandra.
She and Mountain joined in his mind. He was weary. Her presence assisted him.
One slow, deliberate step after another. It was hard to stay erect, to keep from falling and tumbling down. A ponderous descent.
He was almost at the trailhead, not far from where he had hidden his truck, when he collapsed.
When her father arrived they repeated the pattern of standing and circling. First they stood helplessly in her house, then began moving from room to room, window to window, not knowing what to do, repeating the pattern. Sandra wanted to pace outside but she began to be afraid when night fell. She was not afraid of what might be in the dark. She was afraid of the inside of the house that was completely transparent to her from the outside.
Sandra answered the phone on the first ring. The woman said, “He told me to call you at this number, your home number. Yes, he was clear about it. He said, you would be home. He said, your father would be with you. He said, ‘Drive.’ He was adamant about this though speaking was difficult. He said, ‘Set out going north.’ He said, ‘Tell her, no matter what, go north.’ He asked us to call you again on your cell phone when we know where he will be taken. He said, he knew it would take you many hours. He said, you will have enough time. He made sure I understood. Again, he was certain but I am not sure I understand what he means.”
“Anything else, did Terrence say anything else?” Sandra asked.
“No, but I think this is serious. He isn’t conscious now.”
When John Birdswell’s wife, her mother, Samantha Crow, had died in the hospital, there had been no lack of enforced activities and then there was the baby to hold who was suddenly his entirely. As if from one belly to another, the child had disappeared into his great arms folded around her tiny body that immediately became the stake upon which he rested the rest of his life. Now he had to hold her up, but he had never seen her lean on anyone or anything but herself.
“We’re cursed!” he bellowed as if the extent of his pain would be a sign of strength.
Unexpectedly, Sandra rebuked him but without knowing the source of her optimism, only its necessity. “He will be OK. That’s what his message says.” She had not expected such certainty to emerge from her. But in the moment, she was recognizing that “He will be OK,” was part of holding a field of possibility within which recovery lived.
“You believe in possibility, don’t you?” she dared him, certain that her faith was necessary and that their interaction could also make a difference.
“Yes,” John murmured. “I believe in possibility.” He said it quietly, a throwback to the years he’d had to modify his behavior on behalf of a child who was often asleep in his arms, slung across his shoulder, her mouth slightly open, fully, completely, absolutely, unconditionally trusting him. Now, as if compensating for the quiet days, he often bellowed around her, if not around his patients. His bedside manner was exuberant. His patients were reassured by his confidence in the medicine he offered and his simple love for anyone that came to him for treatment.
This was different. He recognized this immediately from Sandra’s response. The tables were turned and he would have to follow her lead. He stepped back to look at her as she leaned on the counter. This was not a time for reflexive behavior. He took in her stance, her long, confident body so like his own. This was his daughter. He knew her as well as he knew anyone in this life. But at this moment, he didn’t know her at all.
“He will be OK.” These were not the words he had expected to hear. He echoed the words, reaching to copy the exact inflection so that he could incorporate its precise and profound meaning. More than understanding in its usual sense was implied though he had never considered understanding outside of language. He had to slow the phrase down because the words were like a moving car that were taking him somewhere he had never been, where, it seemed, his daughter, unbeknownst to him, had started to live. Not only new territory, distinct territory.
He stopped reviewing the few details that passed for medical information. He was not to consider worst and best scenarios. He was not to review the literature now or later. He was traveling, traveling down, descending into a terrain he had never traversed before. There was an enormous stillness around and within him. As if the entrance of any habitual thought would demolish this experience. Everything he was experiencing was wordless and he was required to keep it so. Thank God for meditation; he could do that, and realizing this, was quieted.
He had expected her to continue to pace wildly as she began to do for the first minutes after the phone call; such had always been her way when she was upset but then she stopped abruptly and meticulously filled her suitcase. Now she was still, a different person. Considering. Did she have what they needed? He did not recognize the stillness that was in her. In the hospital, no one was ever still during an emergency and there were always emergencies. The hospital was a field of frantic energies. Because she was not frenetic, he was not frenetic. It was as if she was filled with a power he did not recognize and it was ballast. He was contemplating his daughter as if she were a new patient, assembling signs without interpreting them. The aggregate simply was. A presence. There were no words for this in English. He wasn’t sure there were words in any language. He was reminded of the posture Hosteen sometimes assumed in urgent situations, but not with intention. It came over him without his awareness. As if he were an eagle, a bear, a horse – that confident. It was a way of standing that was motionless despite others’ external frenzy and chaos so it seemed that movement and gravity were creating a single arena of infinite being and Hosteen was of it. Now Sandra was subsumed in it and maybe, he, John, was entering it as well. For Hosteen, his dear friend, it was an energy that could be used. For Sandra, he didn’t know, but she was, he thought, inhabiting another understanding. While for himself? He was only at the very edge of recognizing where he was. He could feel it but it was a foreign country still.
“He will be OK.” Recognition not reassurance.
He didn’t know how close his perceptions were to what was occurring within his daughter. Curiosity, his faithful ally, a family quality, led him to look more closely at her. He trusted himself not to be intrusive or manipulative. Unlike so many, their relationship was dependable as, he thought, such relationships should be. What he saw, what he thought he saw, astounded him. Like a wooden post, that armature within her … was Terrence Green. Terrence was present with them even if he was also on his way to a hospital bed somewhere in Oregon or Washington. Sandra was leaning on Terrence as he, though perhaps unconscious, was holding her up. Inexplicable. Terrence was present here even though he was outside a language and a territory either of them knew.
Terrence would be OK because he knew things they couldn’t know, might never know. He knew why he was called to live and so he knew what this illness or injury meant and what might have caused it, or contributed to this dangerous condition. He knew where the breakdown would take him and why he had to suffer it. He was at a threshold; he could only cross it on his knees. He had been found by two hikers who had, inexplicably, gone off trail. They never did that, they asserted. Something impelled them, they tried to explain. The man went speedily to get help and the woman stayed with Terrence.
“My husband is a runner,” the woman had said on the phone.
“So is my daughter,” John Birdswell added quickly as if the declaration would support the only runner who mattered in the moment. As if they were at a support site, waiting for him with ice, drinks and ace bandages.
There was a pause on the phone. “Terrence? Is that his name? He has no ID on him. We put in a call for help, but Grayson decided to run to the ranger station. He gave us his car keys. And your phone number. We’re not quite sure where we are. He will bring help back. Grayson agreed your friend would be safe with me.”
John Birdswell thought he was seeing the two of them. Terrence on the ground. The woman seated next to him, her legs folded to the side, holding his hand. Khaki pants. A brown blouse. A black down jacket. Her hand was square, soft and warm. Comforting.
“What’s your name?” he asked, meaning somehow to buttress her. As soon as he asked, he knew it wasn’t necessary. She had already crossed the line from stranger to friend and the usual exchanges unnecessary. Though he knew she was holding her phone, that isn’t what he saw. He saw her focused on Terrence, the intimacy of her narrow feet in white socks, her boots by the tree that shaded the two of them, her broad, freckled hand very still on Terrence’s arm. The jacket now folded under his head.
“Charity,” the woman said. “It’s a silly name to have for a moment like this. But it is my name.”
The response was obvious and so he said nothing. John said, “Thank you, Charity. We will finish packing and you can reach us as we drive.” She hung up.
When the helicopter arrived, circling and coming in lower and circling and descending until a landing was possible, they were already in the car. Sandra answered the second call as she had the first. Terrence had come back to consciousness, circling up one vortex calling forth another, if only for a moment. “I am going to be OK,” he had said, using the phone belonging to the medic. “It will take a while. I don’t know where they are taking me. It is a bleed. An aneurism.” There were long spaces between sentences filled with his jagged breath.
John Birdswell and Sandra had the phone on speaker and were listening intently.
“Anything else?”
“I’m very cold. Like the mountain. We’re kin.”
“Why do you think it is a bleed?” John asked.
“I can taste the blood coming through the roof of my mouth.”
“You wouldn’t taste …”
“I know,” Terrence said, “and John, I know.”
Once again, John Birdswell understood all his particular knowledge, training and experience, was irrelevant. As if he was a doc on the reservation again, he didn’t have the last word. He looked at Sandra in the dark car. Terrence was going in and out of consciousness and Sandra was going in and out of stillness. It was night and they were speeding north on US 5. The Medic took his phone back and said he’d call them from Portland or wherever he would finally take him. “Be ready to travel,” he said. “We’re in the car,” she said. “I packed quickly. And my father always has a suitcase with a change of clothes in the car. He’s a country doc.”
Then the medic gave the phone to Terrence again. “Be very brief,” he said.
Terrence was broken. But all the pieces were laid out, as they might be, if an old pot or body was to be reconstructed from shards.
“I will be OK,” Terrence repeated as if he were giving an order.
“I am here, Terrence,” she said, meaning so many different things.
Then the medic disconnected the phone, or Terrence lost connection, or both.